realpulse

REALPULSE EXPLAINED / 01

One working life.
Two retirement systems.

What if the money paid into Social Security had been invested instead?

Follow the same contributions from the first paycheck through retirement. See what each system provides—and who carries the risk.

Explore the comparison

01 Set a working life

Starting salary alone works. Later earnings follow national wage growth.

Try:
Add a current or ending salary Optional

We estimate a smooth salary path between the two figures. If the endpoint comes before retirement, earnings then follow national wage growth. Actual job changes can be uneven. An endpoint in the starting year uses the starting salary.

Adjust assumptions Employee + employer · 2.5% inflation

This example assumes continuous W-2 employment and retirement at the start of the selected year. Income taxes and the value of disability / survivor coverage are excluded from the numerical comparison.

02 Same contributions. Different promises.

All results in 2025 dollars

45 working years — contributed by employee + employer

Medicare excluded
DEFINED BENEFIT

Social Security

—/ month

Estimated starting benefit · scheduled under current law

What you receiveIncome for life

Benefits adjust with the program’s cost-of-living rules. There is no personal balance to spend down.

Longevity risk is pooled
DEFINED CONTRIBUTION

An invested account

—/ month

Starting withdrawal · matched to Social Security

Hypothetical account at age 67—

The same contributions, invested in the S&P 500 with dividends reinvested, less the selected fee.

You carry market and longevity risk

Social Security also provides disability and survivor protection. The invested account shown here does not purchase replacement coverage. See the full tradeoffs ↓

FOLLOW THE MONEY

What’s left after paying the same income?

The account funds withdrawals that match Social Security, including cost-of-living increases.

Future markets

Illustration: 6% annual nominal return before fees. Future inflation: 2.5%.

Solid = history · dashed = projection
Retirement account balanceLoading comparison.
75100
Calculating the comparison…

What if the account paid a different income?

Withdrawals rise with the same COLAs. Payments stop when the account cannot fund them; there is no borrowing.

Market history ends in 2025. Future paths are scenarios, not predictions or probabilities.

THROUGH THE SELECTED AGE

Income received. Money remaining.

Two different measures of what retirement provides.

Social Security income received—From age 67 to 95
Investment withdrawals received—At the matching income target
Investment balance remaining—Potentially available to heirs

THE REAL TRADEOFF

An income promise.
An account you own.

The difference is larger than a return percentage. Each system allocates risk, protection, and ownership differently.

What mattersSocial SecurityInvested account
Living a long lifeRetirement benefits continue for life.Income depends on the balance and withdrawal decisions. The account can run out.
Market downturnsYour benefit is not tied to stock prices.Losses matter most when you are also selling investments to pay living costs.
Lower lifetime earningsThe benefit formula replaces a larger share of lower earners’ wages.The same return applies to each invested dollar; smaller contributions build smaller accounts.
Disability & survivorsQualifying workers and families receive additional protections.The balance can support a family, but equivalent insurance would cost extra.
Leaving money behindEligible survivors may receive benefits; there is no personal account to inherit.A remaining account balance can pass to heirs.
Policy & fundingBenefits and taxes depend on law. Scheduled benefits face a funding shortfall.Account rules and taxes can change. Returns and adequate income are not guaranteed.
A personal comparison is not a national transition plan.

Today’s payroll taxes help pay today’s beneficiaries. Redirecting them would require another way to honor existing obligations. This illustration does not price that transition or replacement insurance.

Real systems can combine both ideas.

AU

Australia

Employer-funded superannuation accounts sit alongside a public, means-tested Age Pension.

How the system works ↗

Open the numbers.

Public sources. Visible assumptions. Calculations you can inspect.

How the comparison is calculated

Benefits use the highest 35 years of wage-indexed covered earnings, divided by 420 months and rounded down. We apply the bend points for the year age 62 is reached, COLAs, and the adjustment for claiming age. Future bend points follow the statutory wage-indexing formula. Future wage caps use an illustrative wage-indexed approximation rounded to $300.

Contributions arrive at each month’s end. The annual stock return is converted to an equivalent monthly rate; this does not recreate the actual monthly market path. Withdrawals occur after monthly growth. December COLAs affect December benefits. Annual inflation conversion uses average CPI-U. Birthdays, retirement, and work years are simplified to calendar-year boundaries.

Dollar figures are rounded for readability. Tax totals include OASDI; Medicare is excluded. The model assumes continuous covered W-2 employment, excludes income taxes and investment tax drag, and does not calculate spousal, survivor, disability, or special-case benefits. It is a systems illustration, not an individual SSA benefit determination.

The S&P 500 is a stock-market benchmark, not itself a retirement system. This is a hypothetical index investment, including periods before index funds were available. Fees are illustrative. All comparisons should be read with these assumptions.

What is historical, and what is assumed?

Stock returns, average wages, and annual CPI are historical through 2025. Published Social Security tax rules, wage caps, bend points, and COLAs use available announced values, including known 2026–2027 amounts where published. Any remaining future values are modeled assumptions. Source snapshot: October 24, 2026.

Future scenarios are deliberately simple illustrations: 6% or 3% nominal annual growth before fees, or a downturn of −30%, −10%, +5%, +8%, and +10%, then 6%. The downturn begins at retirement or the first future year if retirement is already historical. Observed market years are never replaced by a scenario. These paths are not probability estimates.

Default future inflation and COLA: 2.5%. Default future nominal wage growth: 3.5%. Default investment fee: 0.10% annually. Changing inflation also changes the purchasing-power conversion. Wage profiles follow the national average wage index; that is an average, not a median salary.

Social Security funding: scheduled versus payable benefits

We show scheduled benefits under the current benefit formula. That is different from what existing financing alone is projected to support.

The 2026 Trustees summary projects that the retirement and survivors trust fund can pay full scheduled benefits until the fourth quarter of 2032. At depletion, continuing income is projected to cover 78% of scheduled benefits. Congress could change taxes, benefits, or financing. This comparison does not assume a particular legislative response or silently reduce benefits.

Read the 2026 Trustees summary ↗
Sources & downloadable dataset
Year-by-year calculations for this example

Working-year earnings, taxes, returns, and balances; then retirement income and withdrawals. Monetary columns use dollars in the stated year.